The Phoenix Network:
About  |  Advertise
Adult  |  Moonsigns  |  Band Guide  |  Blogs  |  In Pictures
Media -- Dont Quote Me  |  News Features  |  Talking Politics

The political story everyone missed

John Robitaille almost beat Lincoln Chafee in the race for the corner office. How did he come so close -- and why did the local media leave him almost wholly unvetted?
By DAVID SCHARFENBERG  |  December 22, 2010

THE ALMOST-GOVERNOR Robitaille flew under the radar.

The headlines from this year's gubernatorial race were Democrat Frank Caprio's indelicate suggestion that the leader of the free world "shove it" and Lincoln Chafee's historic victory as Rhode Island's first independent governor.

But the most stunning and underreported story of the race — of the entire year in politics, for that matter — was the near victory of Republican John Robitaille, who finished just two points short of Chafee on Election Day, 36 to 34 percent.

Think of it: Rhode Island, staring down its worst economic crisis in a generation, came within a few thousand votes of handing the corner office to a largely unvetted public relations specialist with no experience in elected office.

How did Robitaille, virtually ignored until the final weeks of the campaign, get so close? How was everyone caught so off guard?

And what does the opaque picture of the almost-governor tell us about the state of Rhode Island's newspaper of record?


In late 2009 and early 2010, all the buzz on the GOP side centered around Steve Laffey, the combative and quotable former mayor of Cranston.

And when Laffey pulled up his tent with a typical rhetorical flourish — declaring that the state was not ready for the strong medicine he would prescribe — Robitaille's official entry to the race had the feel of an afterthought.

Here was a guy who no one had heard of, who had no personal fortune, who would be no factor. He made a weak showing in the early polls. Fundraising was a struggle. And the media — the Phoenix included — gave the candidate little ink.

Robitaille, a communications specialist, says he was unsurprised by the lack of "free" or "earned" media — as opposed to paid ads — at the outset. "I knew that earned media — you had to earn it," he says.

But Giovanni Cicione, chairman of the state Republican Party, allows for a bit more disappointment, calling the Providence Journal's early inattention "shortsighted" and "wrong."

From his perspective, the seeds of a competitive bid were always there. A GOP candidate running for major office, he says, is virtually guaranteed 28 to 32 percent of the vote — no small sum in a multi-candidate race. And a national swell of anti-incumbent, anti-Democratic feeling seemed bound to add a few points to the total.

Indeed, as one Democratic operative notes, there is an argument to be made that Robitaille was the only of the three major candidates with a natural base: Chafee, the independent, was running outside the party structure and Caprio's explicit bid for conservative support seemed destined to alienate the progressives and labor interests who form the backbone of the Democratic Party.

But there was little opportunity to alter the dynamic in the early months of the campaign. With no competitive GOP primary for governor, the press was destined to keep its distance. And because Rhode Island stages its primaries so late — in September — Robitaille had to wait months before he could get access to the public campaign funds that would allow him to pay for an advertising campaign of any significance.

1  |  2  |  3  |   next >
  Topics: News Features , John Sununu, Scott MacKay, Mark Arsenault,  More more >
| More
Add Comment
HTML Prohibited

 Friends' Activity   Popular   Most Viewed 
[ 01/02 ]   Leonard Nimoy: "Secret Selves"  @ Massachusetts Museum of Contemporary Art
[ 01/02 ]   The Blue Flower  @ Loeb Drama Center
Share this entry with Delicious
  •   WHO WINS? WHO LOSES?  |  December 29, 2010
    Quick question: who won the Rhode Island elections in November?
    The headlines from this year's gubernatorial race were Democrat Frank Caprio's indelicate suggestion that the leader of the free world "shove it" and Lincoln Chafee's historic victory as Rhode Island's first independent governor.
  •   THE CELTICS AND THE BIRTH OF THE REAL NBA  |  December 22, 2010
    The Providence Journal 's estimable sports columnist, Bill Reynolds, is out with a new book, Rise of a Dynasty: The '57 Celtics, the First Banner, and the Dawning of a New America .
  •   NOT WAITING FOR SUPERMAN  |  December 15, 2010
    Just off the main drag in Federal Hill, in a brightly painted office, a series of hand-written notes hang on the wall. This is headquarters for Teach for America Rhode Island, the local branch of a booming nonprofit that recruits top-tier college graduates to teach in some of the nation's toughest public schools.
  •   THE 2011 POLITICAL FORECAST  |  December 15, 2010
    The great wave election of 2010 did little to reshape Rhode Island's Congressional delegation. Neither of the state's senators faced re-election and Democrats held onto both House seats, with Congressman-elect David Cicilline replacing the retiring Patrick Kennedy.

 See all articles by: DAVID SCHARFENBERG

RSS Feed of for the most popular articles
 Most Viewed   Most Emailed 

  |  Sign In  |  Register
Phoenix Media/Communications Group:
Copyright © 2011 The Phoenix Media/Communications Group