The Phoenix Network:
About  |  Advertise
Adult  |  Moonsigns  |  Band Guide  |  Blogs  |  In Pictures
Flashbacks  |  Media -- Dont Quote Me  |  News Features  |  Phillipe And Jorge  |  Stark Ravings  |  The Editorial Page  |  This Just In

Revenge of the nerds

For the first time since JFK, 'the best and the brightest' are back in the White House. Will Ivy-League intellect be enough to set the country straight?
By STEVEN STARK  |  January 21, 2009


Barack Obama's new administration has been characterized many ways — as a return to liberalism, a Chicago Mafia, and the harbinger of a new age.

But what it represents on a grander, political-science level is the return of the intellectual establishment to the seat of power in American politics. Or call it revenge of the nerds.

If there's one overriding theme that characterizes Obama's team, it is that anyone who went to Harvard (or another high-powered elite school) has his full trust. The Boston Globe calls the newly ensconced White House team "Cambridge on the Potomac." And Obama's actions and rhetoric confirm the same impulse. One Obama advisor even told ABC's George Stephanopoulos that the cabinet would be a mixture of Abraham Lincoln's "band of rivals" and "the best and the brightest." In truth, we've seen a lot more of the latter than the former.

Thus, as promised, Obama is moving beyond leftists and rightists and setting up "the establishment" in its place. The establishment, of course, generally eschews partisanship. Thus, the president has no problem meeting with conservative columnists such as George Will or David Brooks — they're part of a related establishment, the media establishment. Even the Internet pundits ushering his charge, Arianna Huffington and Andrew Sullivan, are graduates of, ahem, Oxbridge.

It should be no surprise that a figure who got his real break by attending Harvard Law School and becoming president of the Harvard Law Review should be so bewitched by the intellectual establishment. And, to the extent Obama has promised to be a post–Baby Boom president, it's no shock that he is resurrecting an admiration for the power bloc that was anathema to the original '60s rebels. (And it was their anti-authoritarian impulses that dominated our political life for decades.)

But it's worth remembering how radical a change this is in our political life. "The best and the brightest" and "the wise men" had absolutely no use for George W. Bush. And, to be honest, they weren't crazy about his father (patrician, but still too Texan), Bill Clinton (too Arkansas), Ronald Reagan (too Hollywood and undependent on them), Jimmy Carter (he made them a sworn enemy), Richard Nixon (of course), and Lyndon B. Johnson (who despised the Harvard people who had surrounded John F. Kennedy). In fact, in a comparison that Obama would welcome, you have to go back to JFK — and then Franklin D. Roosevelt — to find the last presidents so in tune with the nation's Ivy League elite.

The good news, of course, is that this elite comprises people who are very smart, and smarts are what we need to get out of the economic mess we're in. "Egghead" should no longer be a pejorative term, as it has been for two generations, going back to the original egghead in the 1950s, Adlai Stevenson.

But there are two dangers for the new president. The first is that he may be setting himself up for a populist political revolt. Syndicated columnist Froma Harrop recently wrote that one thing separating our current era from FDR's is the lack of populist figures to challenge the status quo, such as Huey Long or Upton Sinclair. Well, give it time. The economic crisis has been with us only a few months, and Obama's administration isn't yet a week old. If the crisis lingers, the populists will appear. And, even when it's over and people suddenly realize their 401(k)s are never coming back, they will be looking for scapegoats, only to find that some of the major potential villains, such as Larry Summers (who failed to regulate the markets adequately the first time around when he should have as Bill Clinton's treasury secretary), have desks right next to the president. If that begins to happen, Obama shouldn't be shy about letting heads roll.

The second danger was persuasively outlined by David Halberstam in his seminal history, The Best and the Brightest (a term used ironically) — the story of how the best brains of the '60s got us immersed in the Vietnam War. It might be described as the conceit of intellect. Put another way, there's a story that, when Socrates went to see the Oracle at Delphi, the Oracle told the philosopher he was the wisest man in Greece. Socrates took that to mean that he knew enough to know that he didn't know.

Can one say the same about Obama and his team? There is an extremely fine line between audacity and arrogance. Not confusing one with the other may be the toughest challenge facing the new administration.

To read the "Presidential Tote Board" blog, go to Steven Stark can be reached at

Related: Rise of the political bogeyman, President Obama, Money matters, More more >
  Topics: Stark Ravings , audacity, Barack Obama, Harvard,  More more >
  • Share:
  • RSS feed Rss
  • Email this article to a friend Email
  • Print this article Print
Re: Revenge of the nerds
The linkages of Harvard, Kennedy, and Obama will soon be left for souviner hunters. Mr. Obama did a quick 3yr law school tour and was never emersed in that culture as much as his campaign nuanced. There's something far more ominous about his appointments which this article come close to tagging, the backs off.
With his tony, avant-garde campaign successfully throwing off the hollow baby-boomer mantra of, “I disagree, therefore I am”, and after beating the reactionary right like a piñata, the new fast-tracked, fast paced, ‘President Cool’ appears the topic in the realm of parlor games and the guess work which accompanies both agenda and administration buildup. Growing numbers want a stroll into the clearing, some face time, and there break into one of those ‘well, look’ conversations. Such things never, ever happened in the political career of the guy from Illinois, and with all transparency and full disclosure, it ain’t happening now. Mr. Obama’s centrist and right-of center appointments are proving unsettling to those perceiving themselves as his ‘base’.   The new Gautama has not gathered in the garden with the victims of post-modernity, black and white, carrying their pre-existing conditions, their mythologies, and their hyper-vigilance like begging bowls in tow. Rumor and fear abound in such periods, and such expectations are the residue of the permanent campaign. As things unfold, some of the faithful view an increasing, if not pre-planned consortium with the ‘them’, the ‘others’.   This season was axiomatic. It was promissory and cruelly exhilarating. For the loser, nothing softens its ending, and for the ideologue, like the junky, nothing contains a numbing. The historic newness of things can be muddied, scores settled, wounds re-opened and so forth…and so on. And such a season both favored and gave legs to the Obama phenomena, a thing the density of ambition and illusion has continued to shamelessly propel.
By jeffmcnary on 01/24/2009 at 7:11:18
Re: Revenge of the nerds
As we saw during the 1960's, an Administration of "the best and the brightest" is not a guarantee of success.Nonetheless, given the severity of the problems we face, I'd at least rather start with the "best and the brightest" rather than the "worst and the dumbest". (Oh wait, didn't they just leave?)
By Vic in Chicago on 01/26/2009 at 5:04:24

Share this entry with Delicious
  •   APPEARING ACT  |  March 10, 2009
    Obama's 'personal presidency' is overexposing the Commander in Chief, and painting him into the corners of the Oval Office.
  •   THE ELEPHANT ALSO RISES  |  March 03, 2009
    The GOP has a bumpy road ahead of them, but if they're savvy they'll be back in power sooner rather than later.
  •   WISH UPON A CZAR  |  February 18, 2009
    Paul Krugman could be Obama’s economic dream come true
  •   HOW TO SAVE YOUR LOCAL NEWSPAPER  |  February 12, 2009
    Six steps for staving off the death of print
  •   WITH FRIENDS LIKE THESE  |  February 06, 2009
    Obama should worry less about befriending the GOP and more about keeping his own party in line

 See all articles by: STEVEN STARK

RSS Feed of for the most popular articles
 Most Viewed   Most Emailed 

  |  Sign In  |  Register
Phoenix Media/Communications Group:
Copyright © 2009 The Phoenix Media/Communications Group