CD Reviews

The Rural Alberta Advantage | Departing

Saddle Creek (2011)

By RYAN STEWART | March 23, 2011

2.0 Stars

On their debut, Hometowns, Toronto's Rural Alberta Advantage sounded like a band in search of an identity. On one track, they were a competent folk-country outfit, on the next, twinkly-eyed synth-poppers. It was a bit of a mess, but there were moments when they seemed to be onto something. So surely the improved focus on Departing must be to their benefit, no? Well, not so much - of all the possible directions the band could have taken, they decided on generic coffeehouse folk pop, with predictably pleasant-yet-dull results. Lead singer Nils Edenloff has a nasally twang that's generated some comparisons with Jeff Mangum, but unlike Mangum's voice, his begins to grate somewhere around track eight. The percussion is needlessly prominent; the keyboards now feel ornamental. Lead single "Stamp" gets things mostly right, a blend of intensity and craft with propulsive drumming and Edenloff's vocals working together to create a sense of urgency and anger. This one has a sound that suits them. Perhaps they can try focusing on that next time out.

Topics: CD Reviews , Music, Jeff Mangum, Pop, More

| More

view all

[ 05/29 ] Brad Hooper @ Andy's Old Port Pub

[ 05/29 ] karaoke with DJ Ponyfarm @ Slainte

ARTICLES BY RYAN STEWART

HBO'S VEEP NEEDS MORE MEAN | April 23, 2012
Reality, right now, is so absurd that almost everyone has already adopted a "laugh-to-keep-from-crying" approach to the news. We don't need someone to tell us how truly horrifying our political landscape is. So what's a satirist to do?

NOT MUCH 'MAGIC' ON STARZ'S NEW DRAMA | April 05, 2012
Premium networks play by different rules from the rest of television, but Starz has taken things to a new extreme: they've twice renewed shows before episode one even aired.

REVIEW: HOUSE OF LIES | January 05, 2012
In a television landscape dominated by protagonists who are murderers, drug kingpins, serial philanderers, and other assorted life-ruiners, Showtime may have finally gone too far.

INTERVIEW: TALKING THE WIRE WITH ROBERT F. CHEW | October 12, 2011
Like many cast members on HBO's The Wire, Robert F. Chew is originally from Baltimore and therefore has firsthand experience with much of the urban decay the show depicts.

BREAKING BAD KEEPS TOPPING ITSELF | October 05, 2011
In this age of Hollywood business dealings breathlessly tweeted within minutes of their consummation, passersby cell phone set photos that reveal major plot points, leaked scripts and leaked episodes, Vince Gilligan has accomplished something rare indeed.